The Edinburgh Agreement (full title: Agreement between the United Kingdom Government and the Scottish Government on a referendum on independence for Scotland) is the agreement between the Scottish Government and the United Kingdom Government, signed on 15 October 2012 at St Andrew's House, Edinburgh, on the terms for the Scottish independence referendum, 2014.
The need for a referendum was due to the consequences of the 2011 Holyrood elections, where the SNP won a substantial majority and formed the first majority government in the Scottish Parliament. The system was designed specifically to prevent a non-Unionist party from securing a majority and this came as a shock to the establishment. Politics in Scotland (and also to some extent in the rest of the UK) had entered somewhat uncharted territory.
An SNP manifesto commitment to an Independence Referendum came to the fore. To satisfy this requirement, discussion and subsequent agreement with Westminster was necessary.
Both governments agreed that the referendum should:
have a clear legal base
be legislated for by the Scottish Parliament
be conducted so as to command the confidence of parliaments, government and people
deliver a fair test and decisive expression of the views of people in Scotland and a result that everyone will respect
The governments agreed to promote an Order in Council under Section 30 of the Scotland Act 1998 to allow a single-question referendum on Scottish independence to be held before the end of 2014 so to put beyond doubt that the Scottish Parliament can legislate for the referendum.
The agreement was signed by David Cameron, Prime Minister; Michael Moore, Secretary of State for Scotland; Alex Salmond, First Minister of Scotland; and Nicola Sturgeon, Deputy First Minister of Scotland.
Whether the document was legally binding in theory is a matter of academic discussion. In practice, an Order in Council was in fact approved on 12 February 2013, granting constitutional legitimacy to the referendum held on September 18, 2014.
The Memorandum of Agreement
Purpose of the memorandum
1. This memorandum sets out the elements of the agreement that require legislative provision in the section 30 Order(“the Order”), the draft text of which is annexed to this memorandum, and the elements that have been agreed between the governments on a non-statutory basis.
2. Both governments agree that the principles underpinning the existing framework for referendums held under Acts of the UK Parliament – which aim to guarantee fairness – should apply to the Scottish independence referendum. Part 7 of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 (PPERA), provides a framework for referendums delivered through Acts of Parliament, including rules about campaign finance, referendum regulation, oversight and conduct.
3. Both governments agree that the referendum rules should be based on PPERA, with particular Scottish circumstances, such as the establishment of the Electoral Management Board and subsequent role of the Electoral Commission, reflected in the Referendum Bill.
4. The Order enables the Scottish Parliament to legislate for a referendum that takes place at any point before the end of 2014. The date of the poll will be for the Scottish Parliament to determine and will be set out in the Referendum Bill to be introduced by the Scottish Government. The Order requires the poll for this referendum to be held on a day with no other poll provided for by legislation of the Scottish Parliament.
5. Both governments agree that the referendum question must be fair, easy to understand and capable of producing a result that is accepted and commands confidence.
6. The Order enables the Scottish Parliament to legislate for a referendum with one question on independence. The wording of the question will be for the Scottish Parliament to determine and will be set out in the Referendum Bill to be introduced by the Scottish Government, subject to the Electoral Commission’s review process, as set out in the paragraphs which follow.
7. For referendums delivered by an Act of the UK Parliament, section 104 of PPERA requires the Electoral Commission to review the proposed question and any statement that precedes the question and to report to the UK Parliament on the intelligibility of that question. Section 10 of PPERA also provides that the Electoral Commission can provide advice and assistance to the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Government.
8. Consistent with the provisions in PPERA, the Scottish Government will refer the proposed referendum question and any preceding statement to the Electoral Commission for review of its intelligibility. Interested parties will be able to submit their views on the proposed wording to the Electoral Commission as part of the Commission’s review process, in the normal way. The Electoral Commission will report on the question and this report will be laid before the Scottish Parliament. In turn the Scottish Government will respond to the report, indicating its response to any recommendations that the Electoral Commission may make.
9. The Referendum Bill introduced by the Scottish Government will create a franchise for the referendum. Both governments agree that all those entitled to vote in Scottish Parliamentary and local government elections should be able to vote in the referendum.
10. The Scottish Government’s consultation on the referendum also set out a proposal for extending the franchise to allow 16 and 17 year-olds to vote in the referendum. It will be for the Scottish Government to decide whether to propose extending the franchise for this referendum and how that should be done. It will be for the Scottish Parliament to approve the referendum franchise, as it would be for any referendum on devolved matters.
11. The Scottish Government’s decision on what to propose to the Scottish Parliament will be informed by the analysis of responses to its consultation exercise and by practical considerations. The Order does not restrict the extension of the franchise in the case of this referendum. Functions of the Electoral Commission and the Electoral Management Board
12. Both governments agree on the importance of the referendum being overseen in an impartial way by bodies that can command the confidence of both sides of the campaign. The Electoral Commission is responsible for overseeing referendums held under PPERA.
PPERA gives the Electoral Commission responsibility for:
commenting on the wording of the referendum question;
registration of campaigners;
designating lead campaign organisations;
regulating campaign spending and donations;
giving grants to lead campaign organisations;
publishing guidance for permitted participants;
reporting on the referendum process;
the conduct of the poll; and
the announcement of the result.
13. The Electoral Commission was also given responsibility for promoting public awareness for voters in the 2011 Welsh and UK referendums.
14. Both governments agree that the Electoral Commission should fulfil all these functions in respect of the independence referendum, with the exception of the conduct of the poll and announcement of the result, and the giving of grants (the Scottish Government proposes that there will be no grants of public money to lead campaign organisations). In its role of regulating the campaign and campaign spending, the Electoral Commission will report to the Scottish Parliament.
15. The Scottish Government proposes that the conduct of the poll and the announcement of the result should reflect the arrangements for local and parliamentary elections in Scotland and will be consistent with Scotland’s electoral management structure, co-ordinated by the Electoral Management Board. The poll and count will be managed in the same way as those elections, by local returning officers (designated for the referendum as “counting officers”) and directed by a Chief Counting Officer (CCO). The Scottish Government proposes that the CCO should be the Convener of the Electoral Management Board.
Referendum campaign regulation
16. Both governments agree on the importance of ensuring that the referendum campaign is subject to regulation that ensures that the referendum is fair and commands the confidence of both sides of the debate. The Referendum Bill introduced into the Scottish Parliament by the Scottish Government will include provision for the referendum rules. The governments agree the regulations for the independence referendum campaign should be based on those set out in Part 7 of PPERA.
17. The Order contains specific provision applying some of the PPERA rules to an independence referendum where it would be outside the Scottish Parliament’s legislative competence to make such provision. These provisions relate to referendum campaign broadcasts and the sending of mailshots free of charge.
Referendum campaign broadcasts
18. PPERA provides that only referendum campaign broadcasts made by or on behalf of designated campaign organisations can be broadcast. The Communications Act 2003 requires Ofcom to impose licence conditions on broadcasters requiring them to observe rules set by Ofcom relating to referendum campaign broadcasts.
19. The agreement between the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport and the BBC requires the BBC to broadcast referendum campaign broadcasts and provides that it is for the BBC Trust to determine the basis on which these are broadcast. Both Ofcom and the BBC are required to have regard to the views of the Electoral Commission when making provision in respect of referendum campaign broadcasts. In both the Communications Act 2003 and the agreement with the BBC “referendum campaign broadcast” has the same meaning as in PPERA.
20. The Order makes provision applying the provisions in PPERA relating to referendum campaign broadcasts to an independence referendum. This will mean that Ofcom, the BBC and the Electoral Commission will have the same role in relation to an independence referendum as they would in relation to a PPERA referendum.
Ensuring impartiality of broadcasters
21. The governments agree that it will be important to ensure that broadcast coverage of the Referendum is impartial. Broadcasters, Ofcom and the Electoral Commission will discuss the best way to achieve this.
22. PPERA allows a designated campaign organisation to send one mailshot free of charge to every elector or household. This service is provided by Royal Mail and funded by the UK Parliament through the Consolidated Fund.
23. The Order makes provision applying this provision of PPERA to an independence referendum. This will enable the designated campaign organisations to send out one mail-shot free of charge to every elector or household and for the Royal Mail to recover the cost of postage from the Scottish budget (the “Scottish Consolidated Fund”).
24. Both governments recognise that campaign finance will be an important issue for those campaigning in the referendum, for the Electoral Commission in regulating the referendum, and for people in Scotland. It is important for each of these that the rules are fair and provide a level playing field.
25. The Referendum Bill to be introduced by the Scottish Government will provide for the spending limits in the regulated period for the independence referendum. Both governments agree that the rules and standards set out in PPERA provide the basis for setting the limits.
26. PPERA sets out spending limits for referendums held on a UK-wide basis and a mechanism for the Secretary of State to set the limits for sub-UK referendums by secondary legislation. In setting such limits, the Secretary of State must consult the Electoral Commission and have regard to its views. Whilst the UK Government is not statutorily required to accept the Commission’s recommendations, it regards the guidance of the Electoral Commission as a key consideration and has so far always followed the advice of the Electoral Commission when setting spending limits for referendums held under the PPERA framework. If the Secretary of State does not accept the views of the Commission on the appropriate limits, he or she is statutorily obliged to lay a statement before both Houses of Parliament explaining his or her reasons for departing from its recommendations.
27. The Scottish Government proposes that the regulated period for the independence referendum should be the 16 weeks ending on the date of the referendum. In setting the spending limits for the regulated period for the independence referendum, the Scottish Government will analyse and consider the responses to its consultation, consult with both existing referendum campaigns – neither of which was in existence during the Scottish Government’s consultation period – and have regard to the Electoral Commission’s views and will set out its proposals, and the evidence on which these are based, before the Referendum Bill is considered by the Scottish Parliament. The Referendum Bill, including the proposed spending limits, will be subject to the established Scottish Parliamentary procedures and scrutiny. The Bill, like any other Bill in the Scottish Parliament will, when introduced, be accompanied by a Policy Memorandum. The Policy Memorandum will set out details of the consultation process for setting spending limits and details of any alternative approaches to any of the issues considered. This will include a statement of reasons if there is any departure from the Electoral Commission’s advice on spending limits.
28. Donations to registered political parties are already subject to a regulatory regime established in Part 4 of PPERA. There is, therefore, no need to create an additional set of rules regulating donations to registered political parties solely for the purposes of the referendum. Political parties will not be the only bodies wishing to campaign for a particular outcome at the referendum. The Referendum Bill to be introduced by the Scottish Government will deal with controls of donations to permitted participants that are not registered parties or are minor parties. As under PPERA, permitted participants will not be able to accept certain anonymous donations or certain donations from individuals or organisations from outside the UK.
Government activity during the 28 days before the referendum
29. It is customary for there to be a period before elections in the UK, during which Ministers and other public bodies refrain from publishing material that would have a bearing on the election. Section 125 of PPERA sets out the restrictions that apply to Ministers and public bodies in the 28 days preceding referendums held under that Act. Both governments recognise the importance of respecting the 28-day period prior to a referendum, in the same way that both governments already respect each other’s pre-election period for Parliamentary elections. The Scottish Government will set out details of restricted behaviour for Scottish Ministers and devolved public bodies in the Referendum Bill to be introduced into the Scottish Parliament. These details will be based on the restrictions set out in PPERA. The UK Government has committed to act according to the same PPERA-based rules during the 28-day period.
30. The United Kingdom and Scottish Governments are committed, through the Memorandum of Understanding between them and others,to working together on matters of mutual interest and to the principles of good communication and mutual respect. The two governments have reached this agreement in that spirit. They look forward to a referendum that is legal and fair producing a decisive and respected outcome. The two governments are committed to continue to work together constructively in the light of the outcome, whatever it is, in the best interests of the people of Scotland and of the rest of the United Kingdom.
A pdf version of the Agreement can be viewed by clicking on the icon below. (opens as a pdf in a separate window).