Broadcast on 14 September 2014

BBC Scotland's independence referendum debate from 14 September 2014, as filmed at the Wallace High School in Stirling.

Duration: 1 hour.


  • James Cook.

Panel Members:

  • Stewart Hosie MP, Treasury Spokesman at Westminster, SNP, Yes Scotland.

  • Douglas Alexander MP, Shadow Foreign Secretary, Labour, Better Together.

  • Ruth Davidson, Leader, Scottish Conservatives, Better Together.

  • Elaine C. Smith, Actor and Campaigner, Yes Scotland.

Main questions asked:

  • Why would billion pound multinational corporations issue public warnings if they did not mean it?

  • If Better Together were sincere about more powers, why was it only offered with one week to go?

  • Do the panel feel that the media coverage during the run up to this referendum has been fair and impartial?

  • I want to live in a fairer more equal society, should I vote Yes or No?